Portland Mercury


 
 

« Portland's realtors want your parents dead. | Main | Show Us Your Gills! »

Friday, January 26, 2007

Fashion Will This “Skinny Debate” Ever End?

Posted by Marjorie Skinner on Fri, Jan 26 at 10:48 AM

By far the most proactive of the countries involved in fashion’s skinny model controversy, Spain is not wasting any time in translating its concerns off the runway and onto the rack. It is now meddling with how clothing is sized:

”It is not reasonable for a modern and advanced society to establish stereotypes of beauty that are far removed from the social reality of a community. It is everyone’s commitment that beauty and health go hand in hand,” Health Minister Elena Salgado said at a signing ceremony Tuesday… The Health Ministry’s program aims to end a situation in which a woman who buys a size 40 dress from one designer may not fit in a size 40 garment from another designer. The ministry said the differences sometimes lead women to feel compelled to lose weight… As part of the effort to standardize sizes, the ministry plans to measure 8,500 Spanish girls and women between the ages of 12 and 70 to determine the true shapes of Spanish women’s bodies.

Meanwhile… the rest of the fashion world putters around.

Fashion bosses from Paris, Milan, New York and London have agreed to take part in a debate on how to address eating disorders after some countries took measures to ban ultra-skinny models from their catwalks, according to French fashion’s governing body… “We must inform people, but above all not regulate the sector more than it already is,” said Didier Grumbach. “Regulation is something that weighs down the atmosphere”… Grumbach had initially said the debate on eating disorders did not concern the fashion industry and it did not plan to take part.

It seems obvious that everyone outside of Spain is just kicking up some dust and trying to make it look like they’re “tackling this important issue.”

skinny_model.jpg

Comments

I've seen greyhounds and whippets with more flesh on them.

It's like a corpse in red band-aids. Give her some blood or brains to eat quick!

You know, it's the feminists and their ilk who keep the association between anorexia, fashion, mannequins, magazines, and movies alive.


Is any any actual, creditable hard science pursuing this lead? No. Why? Because anorexia is rather obviously an obsessive-compulsive disorder. Is anyone looking into what movies or magazines cause obsessive handwashing or Tourette's syndrome? No, because they, like anorexia, are brain disorders not socially-caused syndromes.


Nobody blames The Discovery Channel's shows on microbes for causing hand-washing obsessions, but the feminists find an anti-male, anti-establishment goldmine in the anorexia field, because women want reasons to think that it's bad to be thin. Whereas the truth is, as long as you don't go overboard, thin is WAY better than chubby.


Body image issues are a RESULT of anorexia, not its CAUSE. Maybe those so concerned about skinny models would devote their time and energy to getting women to lose weight instead of enabling those looking for a reason to stay overweight, they might do a lot more good.


Compared to female deaths caused by heart disease, where overweight is a huge factor, deaths from anorexia are a relatively less impressive statistic. Almost every one of us knows someone who died from heart disease. Most of you, if you know of anyone who died from anorexia at all, know it second-hand or anecdotally. You're more likely to have known someone killed in a car crash, and as regrettable as traffic fatalities are, they aren't yet regarded as an epidemic, and yet women are more likely to die in a car crash than from anorexia.


Feminism really should be telling us the truth: Most women would be better off if they lost some weight, but that gets into the radioactive topic of women vs. food, and one thing the feminists cynically understand is that women stop listening to you if you tell them they need to eat less.


Showing some skinny models is just part of the charade that will result in the unnecessary death of millions of chow-hungry women, by comparison with a few thousand brain diseased anorexics.


We need to look for a cure for anorexia, but magazines, movies, and mannequins is a dead end.

Comments Closed

In order to combat spam, we are no longer accepting comments on this post (or any post more than 45 days old).

Blogtown End Hits: The Merc's Music Blog MOD: Merc on Design 2008: Merc Election Coverage Mercury Eat and Drink Guide  

Our Friends

Our Enemies