Okay, so this isn’t exactly 
CATHERINE “JASMINE” Perkins was panhandling as usual on the corner of SW 6th and Morrison on Monday morning, June 23.
“Pregnant, broke, and waiting for housing. Need $20, please help,” read her cardboard sign. Perkins—who dresses in the uniform of gutter punks everywhere—makes $30 dollars on an average day. But sometimes, especially now that she’s four months pregnant, she gets too tired to stand for the whole day, so she sits down—and then gets cited for breaking the city’s controversial sit-lie ordinance.
Since last November, Perkins has received 11 such tickets—unless you ask the police bureau, which has vastly underreported data on Perkins and the sit-lie law.
“According to [the police], I’ve only gotten a warning. But that’s bullshit,” she says.
According to the cops’ official statistics given to the mayor’s Street Access for Everyone (SAFE) Oversight Committee, which watchdogs the way the sit-lie ordinance is enforced, Perkins only received one verbal warning under the sit-lie law, back in February (a warning is a prerequisite for a citation). But a search of the Oregon Judicial Information Network confirms Perkins’ story: She got a citation each month between November 2007 and January 2008, four in February, one in March, two in April, and one in May.
It’s not clear why or how Perkins’ citations fell through the data-reporting cracks, but the omission of her data is politically significant: Her repeated ticketing suggests the ordinance is being used overwhelmingly to target street kids—something proponents of the law have denied since its inception. Before the Mercury found Perkins, the street kid with the most repeat citations under the sit-lie law was Correy Gene Douglas Newman, who had received three, according to the city’s data.
“I feel disappointed that it seems, somewhere in the process, data is slipping through the cracks,” says Patrick Nolen, community outreach organizer for homeless nonprofit Sisters of the Road—which left the SAFE Oversight Committee last month to campaign for a repeal of the law.
Perkins has a blunter perspective.
“They don’t want the public to know how many tickets they’re giving to homeless people,” says Perkins, who has racked up $3,000 in fines for the citations. “The cops are just doing this because their bosses are telling them to come down here and harass the homeless and drive them out of downtown. You only matter if you’ve got money, nowadays.”
“I’m concerned,” says the SAFE Oversight Committee Co-Chair, Monica Goracke of the Oregon Law Center. “I understand this is the result of a data error, but I don’t know yet whether it’s an isolated error, or if there are other citations that weren’t captured in the data collection that normally happens.”
The police bureau is now doing an exhaustive data review by hand, and Goracke expects to be updated at the next SAFE meeting on July 10. The mayor’s office, police bureau, and Portland Business Alliance did not respond to requests for comment by press time.
I find it hard to believe there are NO resources in the city for homeless pregnant women. As a matter of fact I think that would be a total crock.
She is on a waiting list to get into housing. The list is long. You were saying?
This damn sit-lie ordinance! Unfairly targeting those who sit-lie on the downtown streets! Just like drug laws unfairly target those who manufacture, sell and possess drugs. And those damn speeding laws that unfairly target speeders. And those damn theft laws that unfairly target thieves! Enough already! Did you know that the majority of people arrested for Domestic Violence assaults are WHITE MALES! How racist and sexist is that!!!!
Why does anyone think that the rest of us owe her anything for being lazy and getting pregnant? So she gets tickets for essentially panhandling. Big deal. Get a job and be responsible. Maybe the Portland Mercury will give her a job.
Why does anyone think that the rest of us owe her anything for being lazy and getting pregnant? So she gets tickets for essentially panhandling. Big deal. Get a job and be responsible. Maybe the Portland Mercury will give her a job.
Ever try getting a job without an address? Or wearing nice clothes to an interview when you have nothing? Or able to shower before work when you have no shower? Yeah...good luck getting a job. This is why she needs help. I don't know if she is lazy or not, but most homeless people are not lazy, just mentally ill or have had horrible things happen to them. So Tony, it is easy to say those things when you have opportunities that not all have.
I am shocked, shocked to find the PPB lying/misreporting/being inept...shocked.
no wonder they fight so hard against oversight. it should be interesting to see what the results of the recount is.
Keep up the great work trying to get to the truth, Matt - be sure to report on the July 10th update. I would be interested to know how this error came about. Was it one cop, their data system, etc.
| in Music | in Visual Arts | in Books |
|---|---|---|
Neil DiamondAfter canceling his September performance in Portland, Neil Diamond is back and ready to blow us out of our seats! Fine, maybe he won’t “blow us,” but I bet he’ll come to the stage locked and loaded with hits such as “Cherry, Cherry,” “Sweet Caroline,” and “I’m a Believer.” And does anybody remember “Heartlight”? I do! WSH Rose Garden, 1 Center Court St., $55-120, 8:00 PM |
| Most Popular | I, Anonymous | Best of the Merc |
|---|---|---|
|
hey lover
Maybe the reporting folks just didn't open that email, like the Bush Administration did with a pesky EPA order.