This Week in the Mercury

A Month of Letters

Books

A Month of Letters

Mary Robinette Kowal's Hand-Written Challenge


Bombad Three Dees!

Film

Bombad Three Dees!

Ooo! Da Phantom Menace! Deesa Besto Star Warsie!



Monday, September 28, 2009

Barton For Senate: But Without Bus Support?

Posted by Matt Davis on Mon, Sep 28, 2009 at 1:42 PM

State Representative Brent Barton is revealing himself as an eager ladder climber.* (*That's not a value judgment, hell, it's practically a ringing endorsement where I come from.) Having only gotten elected to the house last year, the youthful corporate lawyer is already hoping to become a senator in the district, which stretches out into Hood River. Senator Rick Metsger, who currently represents the district, announced last Thursday that he won't seek reelection for the seat. Barton is the first to declare interest in a run.

brentbanner1.jpg

BARTON: STATE REPRESENTATIVE, WANTS TO BE STATE SENATOR

barton.jpg

BARTON: MAY VERY WELL DE-FRIEND ME ON FACEBOOK NOW

Barton is a board member of the Oregon Bus Project, which went out and did some heavy door knocking for him in the previous election cycle—knocking on 10,000 doors. Barton only defeated his opponent Linda Flores by 52% to 48% in the November general election, by 14,033 votes to 13,057 votes.

But Barton got a bad rap in some quarters following his vote with Republicans against a bill to protect the Metolius River from development, earlier this year. Barton's law firm, Perkins Coie, happened to represent the developers, Dutch Pacific, who were planning to build a resort there. Barton filed a "potential conflict of interest" on the measure before voting, but still, voted against it anyway. He adds that he does not represent Dutch Pacific, personally, as a client at Perkins Coie.

"It's not like I want to pave the Metolius," Barton told the Oregonian in June, after voting, effectively, to pave the way for just that. Barton tells the Mercury he is proud of his environmental record, adding he that he recently scored 81% on the Oregon League of Conservation Voters' scorecard (the other 19% was because he's an "independent thinker," he says, although Barton ranked behind other progressive legislators from the Portland area like Jules Kopel Bailey, Ben Cannon, Michael Dembrow, and Mitch Greenlick). But in this particular instance, regarding the Metolius bill, "I thought the bill as drafted was very poor, and six Democrats agreed with me, initially, including the speaker of the house," says Barton.

"I refuse to let the exception define the rule," Barton continues. "There were plenty of ways I could have gotten behind protecting the Metolius, but the bill in front of me was not something I could have supported."

So, did Barton's voting with the big developers alienate him from the door-knocking progressives who effectively got him elected last time around? The Bus Project certainly seems to be sitting on the fence.

"We haven’t put together a plan, and keeping that seat in forward thinking hands is important," says Henry Kraemer, political director at the Bus. "We haven’t targeted anybody yet, but it’s going to be one of the closest elections if not the closest election in this coming cycle."

Update 1:57: Kraemer clarifies: "Our volunteers decide who we work for, and that takes place over the course of months, and by the time election season comes around, we have hundreds of volunteers excited to knock on doors for people. But that process takes time."

Original post, 1:59: Barton, meanwhile, says he is not concerned about getting door-knocking support from the Bus Project this time around. "The exception does not define the rule. I am extremely proud of my service, I continue to support the Bus Project strongly and they support me," he says. "They have a process, and that process is not yet complete, but I am very confident that the Bus Project will decide to support me when that process is complete," he says. "Nobody agrees with someone else's voting record 100% of the time."

We asked to speak with a volunteer at the Bus Project to find out how they might feel about knocking on doors for Barton, but are yet to hear back. Update, 3:06: We found one! Nick Popenuk chimes in after the jump.

Original post, 1:59:"It's disappointing to me that the story is still about the Metolius," says Barton. "And not about one of the most challenging races this year." More after the jump.

The Metolius protection bill was eventually passed by just one vote, after house representative Larry Galizio changed his vote, prompting accusations that he may have done so only to secure a job with help from Governor Ted Kulongoski.

As I explained to Barton, the story might well be about the race if he'd voted differently on the Metolius question. But that's politics. And speaking of politics, the question remains as to whether a credible opponent will emerge to run against Barton in the race for the vacant senate seat. It's unlikely. So he's likely to win the reluctant endorsement of progressives this time around, regardless.

Nevertheless, others are less sure about Barton's progressive credentials. One progressive legislative insider, who declined to be named, says he is "disappointed" in Barton's performance this time around. "I'm ready to buy in if he's willing to step up and improve himself to be a bolder legislator than he’s been in this past session," they continue. "He’s not going to get elected without the support of the progressive community, and he has to be a champion to get that support," the insider continues. "His voting record shows that he’s got a lot of potential but he’s not where he needs to be."

Also it's a bit chancey to be running for the senate so soon, isn't it?

"Somehow there's this premise that house experience is a pre-requisite for senate experience," says Barton. "I don't think it's particularly unusual historically speaking, to run for senate after just one term in the house." "Senators Rick Metsger and Ginny Burdick were both elected directly to the senate," says Barton. "Suzanne Bonamici is also an excellent example of someone who served one term in the house who moved over to the senate."

So why is he running for senate?

"I really value what I do, I really love representing my community, and I'm going to continue doing so in the senate," says Barton. "I'm also aware of a political reality," he says. "This is going to be a challenging and vigorous race, and I'm going to be best positioned to win it."

We'll keep you updated on the race.

Update, 3:06pm: Bus volunteer Nick Popenuk writes:

Regarding your Brent Barton article:

I am a Bus Project volunteer who would be happy to knock on doors for Brent Barton. His position on the Metolius bill doesn't concern me, and I'm glad he's not afraid to think independently. He is an intelligent, and honest politician. He has excellent leadership skills, and the potential to be a great State Senator. I think anyone that sits down for a conversation with Brent realizes that he has the best interests of his constituents at heart.

I also appreciate the Bus Project's stance on this election. It is wise to wait and see what other candidates toss their hats into the ring before making an official endorsement. As much as I like Brent, it would be foolish for the Bus (or anyone else) to choose sides in an election without knowing who else is running.

- Nick

 

Comments (12) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
1
Well, he won't be the last. This is a demographically interesting district to represent and Demos will work to find a better candidate because with Rick leaving 26 makes the short list for GOP takeovers.
Posted by J_Renaud on September 28, 2009 at 2:31 PM · Report
2
Yes, it will. This is interesting:

"I'm also aware of a political reality," he says. "This is going to be a challenging and vigorous race, and I'm going to be best positioned to win it."

Read: "The Dems don't have a better candidate, I'm the only one out here. Ya boo."

Without the Obama factor, and given the slimfast nature of the margins, I'd say the GOP has a good chance of winning this one.

And I am still waiting to hear from a Bus Project volunteer who is excited about knocking doors for Barton based on his environmental record.
Posted by Matt Davis on September 28, 2009 at 2:43 PM · Report
3
I wonder why he voted against the Metolius protection bill. That would have been some nice information to include in your article. Otherwise, interesting political reporting. Say what you want Matt, he covers lots of stuff.
Posted by Around on September 28, 2009 at 3:13 PM · Report
4
Barton said he didn't vote for the Metolius protection bill because he didn't like the way it was written.

I said, "show me a well written bill in Oregon, and I'll give you a million bucks," adding that I'd be prepared to overlook a few concerns about land use planning precedents and so-called "due process," if the end result meant protecting one of the state's outstanding areas of natural beauty.

Barton said "you should see some of my bills."

But we agreed to disagree on whether voting for something based on outcome or the intricacies of its language is the right approach.
Posted by Matt Davis on September 28, 2009 at 3:17 PM · Report
5
Very weak answer. But if he's marginally competent with good values, I guess you could a lot worse. Thanks for responding, Matt. Keep up the good(?) work.
Posted by Around on September 28, 2009 at 3:46 PM · Report
6
Hmm...very interesting, Matt. Thanks for covering this story. Say, with Arthur Sulzburger no longer reporting on Multnomah County, will you be doing some reporting work covering the new Charter Review Committee at Multnomah County?
Posted by background on September 28, 2009 at 3:59 PM · Report
7
I guess it reminds me of the Democrats opposing health reform because they're not sure about the nuts and bolts. You can come up with a process concern about any old thing. The question is, are your process concerns more important than the broad thrust of the reform?

If they're not, and in the case of some of the democrats asking bullshit questions about the public option, this is definitely the case, then are you just asking the question to fuck up the reform?

Call me a stickler for good old fashioned integrity, but I'd prefer a straight shooting republican any day than a Democrat who smiles to your face while fucking the progressive cause.

Speaking in (mostly) abstract terms, I mean.
Posted by Matt Davis on September 28, 2009 at 4:00 PM · Report
8
@ Around

"But if he's marginally competent with good values, I guess you could a lot worse."

"Barton got a bad rap in some quarters following his vote with Republicans against a bill to protect the Metolius River from development, earlier this year. Barton's law firm, Perkins Coie, happened to represent the developers, Dutch Pacific, who were planning to build a resort there. Barton filed a "potential conflict of interest" on the measure before voting, but still, voted against it anyway."

Maybe competent with marginal values is more like it?
Posted by RT on September 28, 2009 at 4:18 PM · Report
9
RT,

That would cause me more concerns, I guess. It starts with wanting to do the right thing. The Metolius is a treasure. Its great that against all odds the state managed to protect it. A democrat who wasn't willing to pull his weight on protecting our state's greatest asset, its natural beauty, is probably not my kind of democrat.
Posted by Around on September 28, 2009 at 4:40 PM · Report
10
And remember, this only got protected, in the end, by ONE VOTE.
Posted by Matt Davis on September 28, 2009 at 5:03 PM · Report
11
Selfish move. His House seat was hard to win and it will be even harder for a democrat to win next time around, without the Obama push. Metzger's Senate seat is easier for a democrat to win. Barton should stay where he is, gain a little experience, and then move ahead if he wants.

Posted by selfish move on September 29, 2009 at 2:53 PM · Report
12
(Little behind on this as it's dropping to the bottom of the page but..) I'd be curious to find out who and what else his law firm is representing, as this will obviously effect his voting record in the future. It will also effect my voting record. I just hope another viable candidate steps up. This Metolius issue is a deal breaker for me no matter how poorly the bill was written.
Posted by RT on September 30, 2009 at 10:23 AM · Report

Add a comment

/images/adoftheweek.gif

ad of the day

The Handyman Pro - Your Honey-Do Specialist
Don’t let our name fool you. The Handyman Pro, LLC is a repair and remodel service provider with over 25-years experience. We cover all aspects of construction and repairs for residential and commercial clients.go


post an ad

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC

115 SW Ash St. Suite 600
Portland, OR 97204

Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Production Guidelines | Terms of Use